Reach out to ask any questions about our services! Call or Text (973) 566-5236 or Email Team@PrepForSuccessTutors.com

All The Flaws on the LSAT!

LSAT Identify the Flaw Questions

General Information

Learn how to identify flaws in LSAT arguments, recognize common reasoning errors, distinguish flaw questions from weaken questions, and use effective strategies to select the correct answer.

What Is an Identify a Flaw Question?

This question asks you to identify a flaw in an argument's reasoning. You can assume that the argument is defective in some way. Your job is just to figure out how. Therefore, your answer will generally be a description of something that's wrong with the argument.

What Is the Difference Between Flaw and Weaken?

  • When you're asked to identify a weaken answer, you're essentially finding information in the choices that makes the argument worse than it currently is.
  • When you're asked to identify a flaw, you're not adding any information but rather simply describing why the argument as it stands isn't logically strong. In other words, the argument is already unsound.

How Do We Know It Is an Identify a Flaw Question?

Questions of this kind are worded in a variety of ways:

Examples:
  • The reasoning in the argument is flawed because the argument...
  • The argument commits which one of the following errors of reasoning?
  • The argument's reasoning is questionable because the argument fails to rule out the possibility that...
  • The reasoning above is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it...

What Are Common Trap Answers?

  • Wrong choices will often sound very tempting because they're worded abstractly, and they usually do describe a flaw—just not the flaw that's happening in this argument. Try to avoid the temptation of settling on a choice because "it sounds good"!
  • Beware! You may also occasionally see wrong choices that describe something that is true of the argument, but isn't a flaw.

Common Flaws

Note: These are some of the most often tested flaws, but there are tons of possible flaws that are in arguments.

Causation/Correlation

This is an important type of overlooked possibility, in which the arguer takes two things that happen at the same time (correlation) and concludes that one of those things caused the other (causation).

The arguer overlooks two important possibilities: 1) a third, unaccounted-for thing could actually be the cause, and 2) the cause-and-effect could actually be in the reverse order of what the arguer believes.

Example: Last summer, ice cream sales decreased while homicide rates more than doubled in this region. We should look into selling more ice cream in order to keep people safer.

Sampling

The arguer draws a general conclusion based on what's true about an inappropriate or biased sample.

Example: Everyone I know wants to quit their job, so this country is headed for an employment crisis.

Ad Hominem

The arguer attacks another arguer instead of the argument itself. The identity or motives of an arguer don't affect the validity of that person's argument.

Example: My doctor tells me it's bad for your lungs to smoke cigarettes, but I know he's lying. I saw him furtively smoking a cigarette the other day.

Quantity Versus Percent

The arguer treats quantities and percentages of something as if they're interchangeable, but percentages by themselves don't tell you anything about actual numbers.

Example: 10% of the people with Disease X died last year, whereas 50% of the people with Disease Y died last year. Clearly, Disease Y is hurting our population growth more than Disease X is. (But what if 1,000,000 people had Disease X and only 4 people had Disease Y?)

Lack of Evidence as Proof

The arguer takes a lack of evidence for a conclusion as if that conclusion is definitely wrong. Also known as taking an absence of evidence for "evidence of absence."

Example: Alien life has never been discovered, so it's clear that alien life doesn't exist.

False Dichotomy

The arguer acts like there are only two choices, when in fact it isn't an "either/or" situation.

Example: If you're not with us, then you're against us. The arguer is overlooking the possibility that someone could remain neutral.

Part vs. Whole

When the arguer makes an assumption about one thing based on an entire group or makes an assumption about an entire group based on one thing.

Example: Team A is the best basketball team. Therefore, Billy is a great basketball player since he's on Team A.

Possible vs. Certain

The speaker assumes that because something is possible, then it'll happen.

Example: Last year, we didn't have enough budget money for employee raises, but this year there's plenty of money in the budget. So, it's clear that the company will give out raises this year.

Circular Reasoning

Also known as "begging the question," circular reasoning is when the arguer assumes that his or her conclusion is already true when attempting to prove that same conclusion.

Example: Duplicity is an unattractive characteristic, since it's repulsive to lie and deceive.

Equivocation

The arguer uses a potentially ambiguous term in more than one sense and consequently misleads the reader.

Example: A feather is light, and what's light can't be dark, so a feather can't be dark.

Flaw Strategy

TIPS & TRICKS

✓ Step 1: Skim for a Flaw

See if the arguer is making any of the fallacies that are listed in the previous few pages. Ask yourself a few of the following questions:

  • Is the arguer mistakenly assuming causation when two events are actually only correlated?
  • Is the arguer jumping to conclusions about a larger group of people than the ones being discussed in the support?
  • Is the arguer attacking someone's opinion just because that person's character is questionable?
  • Does the arguer discuss one topic in the support and then draw a conclusion about a different topic?

✓ Step 2: Understand the Disconnect

  • If you don't find a common fallacy, describe the disconnect between the support and conclusion in your own words. Don't try to describe it in a scholarly or academic way—you'll understand and retain it better if you use your own words.
  • It can be helpful to pretend you're on the opposite side of a debate than the passage's arguer—what might you say to rebut? Be as specific as possible; for example, don't respond with "you're making an unwarranted assumption," since that already describes flaws in general.

✓ Step 3: Identify the Choice That Matches Your Prediction; Otherwise, Eliminate Strategically

  • Find the choice that matches your predicted flaw, making sure to not become distracted along the way.
  • If you had trouble making a prediction even after following the guidance above, try throwing out choices that describe something that isn't even happening in the passage. For example, if a choice states that the speaker generalizes from too small a sample, look to see if there's even any indication of a too-small sample in the passage. If there isn't, you can eliminate that choice.
Recent Posts

Leave a Reply