LSAT Match the Flaw / Flaw Parallel Reasoning Questions
Learn how to identify matching flaws in LSAT arguments, recognize common question stems, and compare flawed reasoning patterns to find the correct answer.
What Is a Match a Flaw Question?
This question type is asking you to find a choice containing an argument that exhibits the same flaws as the passage's argument. It's very important to focus on the flaws and not get distracted by the content of the arguments in question. To "match," two arguments only have to exhibit the same flaw; they don't have to be on the same topic.
How Do We Know It Is a Match a Flaw Question?
The wording of the questions will be similar to the following:
- Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its flawed reasoning to the argument above?
- The pattern of questionable reasoning in the argument above is most similar to that in which one of the following?
- Which one of the following arguments exhibits a flawed pattern of reasoning most similar to that exhibited by the argument above?
What Are Trap Answer Choices?
Wrong choices will contain arguments that exhibit either no flaw or a different kind of flaw than the passage does.
Match the Flaw Strategy
TIPS & TRICKS✓ Step 1: Identify the Flaw in the Argument
See if the arguer is making any of the fallacies that are listed in the previous Flaw chapter. Ask yourself a few of the following questions:
- Is the arguer mistakenly assuming causation when two events are actually only correlated?
- Is the arguer jumping to conclusions about a larger group of people than the ones being discussed in the support?
- Is the arguer attacking someone's opinion just because that person's character is questionable?
- Does the arguer discuss one topic in the support and then draw a conclusion about a different topic?
✓ Step 2: Identify the Flaws in the Answers
- You want to go through each answer choice and see if there are any flaws in the answer choices. Make each answer choice a separate "identify the flaw" problem.
✓ Step 3: Match the Argument to the Answers
- Once you have identified the flaw in the argument and all the answer choices, see which answer choice has the same flaw as the original argument.
- The correct answer does not need to match the same content or structure (like the Parallel Reasoning questions); it only needs to have the same flaw.