Reach out to ask any questions about our services! Call or Text (973) 566-5236 or Email Team@PrepForSuccessTutors.com

Best Tips for Weaken Questions on the LSAT

LSAT Weaken Questions

General Information

Learn how to approach LSAT Weaken questions, understand the difference between Flaw and Weaken questions, recognize common question stems, and identify answer choices that undermine an argument's conclusion.

Flaw vs. Weaken

How Are Flaw and Weaken Questions Different?

Weaken Questions

When you're asked to identify a weakener, you're essentially finding information in the choices that makes the argument worse than it currently is when adding that information.

Flaw Questions

When you're asked to identify a flaw, you're not adding any information but rather simply describing why the argument as it stands isn't logically strong. In other words, why the argument is already unsound.

Flaw Strategy!

  • Do a quick skim to see what flaws are already in the passage. Some of the flaws could include correlation vs. causation, sampling errors, and ad hominem arguments (stay tuned for the next email, which will have a full list of all possible flaws).

Weaken Strategy!

  • A specific prediction is usually not recommended, since there are many different ways to weaken a given argument. Therefore, it's best to understand the pieces of the argument and then assess the impact that each choice has when added to the argument.

What Is a Weaken Question?

This question asks you to identify a weakener—information that, if added to the support, would make the conclusion less likely to be true. A weakener won't disprove a conclusion beyond a shadow of a doubt—it'll just worsen the likelihood of the conclusion following from its support.

A specific prediction is usually not recommended, since there are many different ways to weaken a given argument. Therefore, it's best to understand the pieces of the argument and then assess the impact that each choice has when added to the argument.

How Do We Know It Is a Weaken Question?

Example Question Stems:
  • Which one of the following, if true, most undermines the argument?
  • Which one of the following represents the strongest counter to Ana's argument?
  • Which one of the following, if true, casts the most doubt on the reasoning above?

What Are the Common Trap Answers?

The choices in Weaken questions will always either strengthen the argument, weaken the argument, or not affect the argument. Therefore, if you're tackling a Weaken question, the wrong choices will either strengthen the argument or will not affect the argument.

Weaken Strategy

TIPS & TRICKS

✓ Step 1: Eliminate Weak Qualifiers

  • Extreme language (like "few," "some," or "possibly") can be a red flag. Be cautious of answers that make sweeping claims unless the argument explicitly supports them.
  • Similarly, answers that are too vague (e.g., not giving specific details) should be eliminated.
  • For Weakening questions, you want strong language.

✓ Step 2: Identify Any Weaknesses or Assumptions

  • Identify the hidden assumption. These are the key areas where a weakening answer could have an impact. There are three ways assumptions are important for Weaken questions:
    • Spot the Foundation of the Argument: The argument may appear strong on the surface, but it often rests on assumptions that aren't directly addressed.
    • Weaken by Challenging the Assumptions: Weakening the argument often involves undermining the assumptions it relies on.
    • Identify Gaps in Reasoning: Identifying assumptions allows you to spot any gaps in reasoning.

✓ Step 3: Identify Common Weakeners

  • Identify any common patterns: If the argument's conclusion is causal in nature (X caused Y), a common weakener might be to provide an alternative cause (actually, Z caused Y). This is just one example of common patterns you may see on the LSAT. For a closer look at these patterns, you may find it helpful to work through the Flaw chapter.
Recent Posts

Leave a Reply