LSAT Helpful to Know Questions: How to Evaluate an Argument
Learn how to recognize LSAT Helpful to Know questions, identify information that would help evaluate an argument, apply the Yes/No Test, and avoid common trap answers.
What Is a Helpful to Know Question on the LSAT?
Questions that fall into the "Identify What's Helpful to Know" category ask you to identify which answer choice contains information that would help you evaluate an argument.
In other words, you're looking for information that, if you had it, could either strengthen or weaken the argument.
These questions are also commonly referred to as Evaluate the Argument questions because they test your ability to determine what additional information would help assess the strength of a conclusion.
Unlike Strengthen or Weaken questions, you aren't necessarily looking for information that supports or challenges the argument directly. Instead, you're identifying information that would help you decide whether the argument is convincing.
The correct answer identifies information that would be useful in evaluating the argument. Depending on what that information reveals, it could either strengthen or weaken the conclusion.
Real-Life Example of a Helpful to Know Question
When we make decisions in everyday life, we use information in a similar way to reach conclusions.
Imagine you're considering switching jobs. You learn that the new job's office is 3% closer to your home than your current office.
Would that information alone be enough to justify quitting your current job and accepting the new position?
Probably not!
You would likely want to know more information before making your decision, including:
- Salary: Does the new position offer better compensation?
- Company culture: Would you enjoy the new working environment?
- Benefits: Does the new job offer better healthcare, retirement benefits, or paid time off?
- Company mission: Do the company's values align with your priorities?
- Growth opportunities: Would the new role provide better opportunities for advancement?
Each of these details could influence whether switching jobs is a good decision.
LSAT Helpful to Know questions operate similarly. You're identifying what additional information would help you evaluate whether a particular conclusion is supported.
How Do We Know It Is a Helpful to Know Question?
Look for question stems asking which information would be most helpful or useful in evaluating an argument.
Common question stems include:
- "Which one of the following would be most helpful to know in order to evaluate Dave's theory?"
- "It would be most useful to know which of the following in evaluating the politician's argument?"
- "Information about which one of the following would be LEAST useful in evaluating the argument?"
- "Which one of the following would be most useful to determine in assessing the argument?"
Pay close attention to whether the question asks for the MOST useful or LEAST useful information, as this changes what you're looking for.
What Are Common Trap Answers?
Wrong answers in Helpful to Know questions often appear relevant to the topic but do not actually help evaluate the argument's reasoning.
- Irrelevant information: The answer provides details that have no meaningful impact on the conclusion.
- Interesting but unhelpful information: The information relates to the topic but doesn't help determine whether the argument is strong or weak.
- Information that doesn't address the assumption: The answer fails to investigate the reasoning gap between the premises and conclusion.
- One-sided information: The answer might sound supportive, but knowing the information would not meaningfully help evaluate the argument.
Remember that an answer choice does not need to provide the information itself. It only needs to identify information that would be useful to know.
LSAT Helpful to Know Strategy
TIPS & TRICKS✓ Step 1: Use the "Except" Strategy
Watch out for questions asking which information would be LEAST helpful in evaluating the argument.
These questions are essentially EXCEPT questions.
You can rephrase the task as:
"Each of the following would be useful in evaluating the argument EXCEPT..."
This means:
- Four answer choices will provide information that could help evaluate the argument.
- One answer choice will not meaningfully help evaluate the argument.
- The answer that is not useful is the correct choice.
Identifying this distinction before reviewing the answers can prevent you from accidentally selecting useful information when the question asks for the least useful option.
✓ Step 2: Use the "Yes/No" Test
One of the most effective strategies for Helpful to Know questions is the Yes/No Test.
Test the answer choices by turning each one into a question that needs to be answered.
Then consider how different possible answers would affect the argument.
- If the answer is YES: Would this strengthen or weaken the argument?
- If the answer is NO: Would this have the opposite effect?
If a "yes" answer would strengthen the argument and a "no" answer would weaken it, or vice versa, then you have likely identified useful information.
When an answer choice cannot naturally be phrased as a yes/no question, consider two contrasting possible answers instead.
You don't need to know whether the answer is actually yes or no. You're simply testing whether knowing the answer would help evaluate the argument.
✓ Step 3: Find Information to Clarify the Reasoning or Assumption
Pay attention to any assumptions or presumed links in the argument.
The information you're looking for should ideally help clarify the reasoning or determine whether the conclusion is adequately supported.
For example, if an argument assumes that a specific cause leads to an effect, helpful information might confirm or challenge the strength of that causal link.
Ask yourself:
- What is the argument assuming?
- What information is missing between the premises and conclusion?
- Could additional information reveal an alternative explanation?
- Would knowing this information help determine whether the conclusion is justified?
Focus on information that addresses the argument's underlying reasoning rather than information that merely relates to its general topic.
Example of an LSAT Helpful to Know Question
Consider the following argument:
Argument: "Students who attended weekly tutoring sessions scored higher on their final exams than students who did not attend tutoring. Therefore, attending tutoring sessions improves exam performance."
Question: Which one of the following would be most helpful to know in evaluating the argument?
Potential Correct Answer: Whether the students who attended tutoring sessions had similar academic performance to the students who did not attend tutoring before the sessions began.
Applying the Yes/No Test
Turn the potential answer into a question:
"Did both groups have similar academic performance before tutoring began?"
- YES: If both groups performed similarly beforehand, the higher exam scores among tutored students would provide stronger evidence that tutoring contributed to the improvement.
- NO: If the tutored students were already performing better before tutoring began, the argument would be weakened because the difference in exam scores might have existed regardless of tutoring.
Because different answers would meaningfully change how we evaluate the argument, this information is useful to know.
Helpful to Know vs. Strengthen and Weaken Questions
These three LSAT question types are closely related, but they ask you to accomplish different tasks.
- Strengthen questions: Identify information that makes the conclusion more likely to be true.
- Weaken questions: Identify information that makes the conclusion less likely to be true.
- Helpful to Know questions: Identify information that would help determine how strong or weak the argument is.
For Helpful to Know questions, you're evaluating the importance of obtaining additional information rather than selecting a fact that directly strengthens or weakens the argument.
Final Tips for LSAT Helpful to Know Questions
Helpful to Know questions become easier when you understand the argument's assumptions and focus on the information needed to evaluate its conclusion.
- Identify the argument's conclusion and supporting premises.
- Look for gaps or assumptions in the reasoning.
- Use the Yes/No Test to determine whether an answer choice provides useful information.
- Remember that useful information may strengthen or weaken the argument depending on what it reveals.
- Pay special attention to LEAST useful questions and treat them as EXCEPT questions.
- Eliminate answers that are relevant to the topic but do not help evaluate the reasoning.
The goal of an LSAT Helpful to Know question is to identify information that would help evaluate the strength of an argument. The best answer investigates an important assumption or reasoning gap and could meaningfully affect your assessment of the conclusion.