Reach out to ask any questions about our services! Call or Text (973) 566-5236 or Email Team@PrepForSuccessTutors.com

Resolve the Paradox LSAT Question Tips

LSAT Resolve the Paradox Questions: How to Explain a Discrepancy

General Information

Learn how to identify LSAT Explain or Resolve questions, recognize apparent contradictions, find information that resolves a discrepancy, and avoid common trap answers.

What Is an Explain or Resolve Question on the LSAT?

In an Explain or Resolve question, you're asked to identify information that would help explain or resolve a puzzling situation or discrepancy presented in the stimulus.

These questions are also commonly referred to as Resolve the Paradox, Explain the Discrepancy, or Paradox questions.

Usually, the stimulus will present two facts or observations that seem to contradict each other. Your job is to find the answer choice that sheds light on the situation and provides a logical explanation for how both facts could be true.

The correct answer doesn't necessarily prove why the situation occurred. Instead, it provides information that makes the seemingly contradictory facts understandable.

Key Concept:

In Resolve the Paradox questions, your goal is not to choose which fact is correct. Your goal is to explain how both facts could be true at the same time.

How Do We Know It Is an Explain or Resolve Question?

These questions are typically signaled by words such as "explain," "resolve," "account for," or "reconcile."

Common question stems include:

  • "Which one of the following, if true, most helps to explain how the situation could have happened?"
  • "Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy in the information above?"
  • "Which one of the following, if true, most helps to account for the failure described above?"
  • "Which one of the following, if true, most helps to reconcile the two findings?"
  • "Which one of the following, if true, provides the best explanation for the apparent paradox?"

Whenever a question asks you to explain an unexpected result or reconcile seemingly conflicting information, you're likely dealing with an Explain or Resolve question.

What Are Common Trap Answers?

Wrong answer choices in Resolve the Paradox questions generally do one of two things: they make the situation even more puzzling, or they provide information that doesn't actually explain the discrepancy.

Some common traps include:

  • Making the paradox worse: The answer introduces information that makes the apparent contradiction even more difficult to explain.
  • Irrelevant information: The answer provides details that do not meaningfully explain the situation.
  • Explaining only one side: The answer addresses one fact but fails to explain how it can coexist with the other.
  • Restating the discrepancy: The answer simply repeats information already provided without explaining it.
  • Introducing an unrelated issue: The answer shifts attention to another topic instead of resolving the original paradox.

Remember that the correct answer should directly address the apparent conflict between the facts presented in the stimulus.

LSAT Explain or Resolve Strategy

TIPS & TRICKS

✓ Step 1: Understand the Paradox in the Argument

The first step is to understand the situation and identify what makes it puzzling.

Paradox questions typically involve a statement or set of statements describing a situation in which two facts seem to contradict each other.

Look for the contradiction. This could involve two facts that appear difficult to reconcile, an unexpected outcome, or something that seems to violate expectations.

For example:

  • Example 1: "The company has been losing money, yet its sales have increased."
  • Example 2: "John is a regular exercise enthusiast, yet his health is deteriorating."

In both examples, something unexpected is happening.

In the first example, we might expect increasing sales to improve a company's financial performance. However, the company is still losing money.

In the second example, we might expect someone who exercises regularly to experience better health. However, John's health is getting worse.

Your job is to identify the discrepancy between what you're told and what you would ordinarily expect.

Helpful Tip:

Before reading the answer choices, summarize the paradox in one sentence. Ask yourself, "Why is this situation surprising?"

✓ Step 2: Phrase the Paradox as a Question

Once you've identified the apparent contradiction, turn it into a question.

This helps you focus on the information needed to explain the discrepancy rather than getting distracted by irrelevant answer choices.

For example, imagine the stimulus states:

"The population of a city increased even though fewer people were having children."

You could rephrase this as:

"How could the population have grown if fewer people were having children at the time?"

Now you have a clear question to answer.

Possible explanations might involve immigration, changes in mortality rates, or other factors affecting population growth.

Turning the paradox into a question helps you identify the type of information that could resolve it.

✓ Step 3: Find an Explanation of the Question

The correct answer should provide a plausible explanation for why both aspects of the paradox might be true or how they could be reconciled.

The key to resolving a paradox is finding information that removes the apparent conflict by explaining how both facts could coexist under certain circumstances.

Ask yourself:

  • What could explain both pieces of information?
  • How could these two facts be true in the same scenario?
  • Could there be a hidden variable that explains the discrepancy?
  • Is there additional context that makes the situation less surprising?
  • Could a third factor account for the unexpected result?

Look for an answer that directly connects the two seemingly conflicting observations.

The correct choice should make you think, "That explains how both things could happen!"

Example of an LSAT Resolve the Paradox Question

Consider the following LSAT-style example:

Stimulus:

A company reported that its total sales increased by 25% over the past year. However, despite the increase in sales, the company experienced a significant financial loss during the same period.

Question:

Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy?

Potential Correct Answer:

The company's operating expenses increased substantially during the year, exceeding the additional revenue generated by its increased sales.

Why Is This the Correct Answer?

Let's break down the paradox:

  • Fact 1: The company's sales increased by 25%.
  • Fact 2: The company still experienced a financial loss.

At first, these facts may seem surprising because increased sales are often associated with improved financial performance.

However, the correct answer introduces an important piece of information: the company's expenses increased even more than its revenue.

This explains how the company could sell more products while still losing money.

Both facts can now be true without creating a puzzling situation.

Another Example: Exercise and Declining Health

Consider another paradox:

Stimulus:

John exercises regularly and follows a consistent fitness routine. Nevertheless, his overall health has deteriorated over the past year.

Question:

Which one of the following, if true, most helps explain this situation?

Potential Correct Answer:

John has developed a medical condition that is unrelated to his exercise habits and has negatively affected his overall health.

Why Does This Resolve the Paradox?

The apparent contradiction is that John exercises regularly, yet his health is declining.

However, exercise is only one factor that influences a person's overall health.

If John has developed an unrelated medical condition, his declining health becomes understandable despite his regular exercise routine.

The correct answer introduces an additional factor that explains how both observations could be true.

Resolve the Paradox vs. Strengthen and Weaken Questions

Although these LSAT question types may appear similar, they require different approaches.

  • Strengthen questions: Identify information that makes an argument's conclusion more likely to be true.
  • Weaken questions: Identify information that makes an argument's conclusion less likely to be true.
  • Resolve the Paradox questions: Identify information that explains how two seemingly contradictory facts can both be true.

For Resolve the Paradox questions, you generally aren't trying to prove or disprove an argument's conclusion. Instead, you're looking for an explanation of an unexpected situation.

Final Tips for LSAT Resolve the Paradox Questions

To improve your performance on Explain or Resolve questions, remember these strategies:

  • Identify both sides: Clearly understand the two facts or observations that appear to conflict.
  • Find the surprising element: Determine why the situation seems unexpected.
  • Turn the paradox into a question: Ask how both facts could be true simultaneously.
  • Look for missing context: Consider whether another factor could explain the discrepancy.
  • Eliminate irrelevant answers: Avoid choices that don't directly address the apparent contradiction.
  • Don't reject either fact: The correct answer should explain how the given facts can coexist rather than simply denying one of them.
Key Takeaway:

LSAT Resolve the Paradox questions test your ability to explain seemingly contradictory information. Identify the discrepancy, phrase it as a question, and choose the answer that provides the most convincing explanation for how both facts could be true.

Recent Posts

Leave a Reply