Reach out to ask any questions about our services! Call or Text (973) 566-5236 or Email Team@PrepForSuccessTutors.com

Best Identify The Role LSAT Tips

LSAT Identify the Role Questions: Types, Examples, and Strategies

General Information

Learn how to identify the role a statement plays in an LSAT argument, recognize common question stems, and match each statement to the correct answer choice.

What Is an Identify the Role Question?

This question asks you to describe the individual role that a statement is playing in a larger argument. More important than what the statement is saying is what the statement is doing.

The role of a statement is like the role of someone in your life. If someone asked, "What role does your accountant play?" you wouldn't answer, "He likes the Phillies and has two dogs." Instead, you'd describe your accountant's function: "He does my taxes and makes sure my investments are balanced."

How Do We Know It Is an Identify the Role Question?

The questions themselves—sometimes known as question stems—tend to be longer than average, since they usually quote a specific claim from the passage (represented by XXXXX in the examples below).

Examples:
  • The claim that XXXXX plays which one of the following roles in the argument?
  • Which of the following most accurately describes the role played by the claim that XXXXX?

Let's look at a real LSAT example together, and we'll examine some approaches that may help you.

What Are Common Trap Answer Choices?

Wrong choices will often describe a role in the argument that some other claim is playing, or one that doesn't exist at all in the argument. It's important to understand the structure of the argument and what each piece is accomplishing.

Types of Roles

4 Main Role Categories:

1. Conclusion

  • Main Conclusion
  • Intermediate Conclusion

2. Supports Conclusion/Background

  • Premise
  • Intermediate/Subsidiary Conclusion

3. Opposed Conclusion

  • Opposing Conclusion
  • Counterevidence

4. Neutral Conclusion

Common Definitions That Are Helpful for Role Questions

  1. Premise: Supporting the argument's conclusion.
  2. Conclusion: What the argument is trying to prove.
  3. Intermediate Conclusion: Leading to the final conclusion.
  4. Assumption: What the argument relies on but does not state explicitly.
  5. Counterargument: Introduces an opposing viewpoint to the main conclusion.
  6. Example: Used to illustrate a point.
  7. Clarification: Explaining a term or idea.
  8. Recommendation: Suggesting what should be done.

Role Strategy

TIPS & TRICKS

The goal is to break the argument apart to identify the role of each sentence. Use the highlight tool to help visualize the role that each sentence plays.

✓ Step 1: Read the Argument & Highlight Structure

Use what you learned in the Main Conclusion chapter to break the argument down into its premises and conclusion(s).

  • What is the argument trying to prove (the conclusion)?
  • What facts, evidence, or assumptions support the conclusion (premises)?

✓ Step 2: Understand the Role

Determine whether the statement is:

  • A premise supporting the argument's conclusion.
  • A conclusion that the argument is trying to prove.
  • An intermediate conclusion leading to the final conclusion.
  • An assumption that the argument relies on but does not state explicitly.
  • A counterargument that introduces an opposing viewpoint to the main conclusion.
  • An example used to illustrate a point.
  • A clarification explaining a term or idea.
  • A recommendation suggesting what should be done.

✓ Step 3: Match to Answer Choice

  • Eliminate irrelevant choices: As you review the answer choices, eliminate any that don't accurately describe the role the statement is playing in the argument.
  • Consider the function of the statement: The correct answer should describe the function the statement serves in relation to the rest of the argument.

Leave a Reply