Reach out to ask any questions about our services! Call or Text (973) 566-5236 or Email Team@PrepForSuccessTutors.com

Best Necessary Assumptions LSAT Tips

LSAT Necessary Assumption Questions

General Information

Learn how to identify necessary assumptions on the LSAT, distinguish necessary from sufficient assumptions, recognize common question stems, avoid trap answers, and use the Negation Test to find the correct answer.

Necessary vs. Sufficient Assumptions

What Is the Difference Between Necessary and Sufficient Assumptions?

Necessary Assumptions

A necessary condition is something that must be true for a statement or conclusion to hold. It is a condition that, if not met, prevents the conclusion from following as claimed.

In other words, without it, the argument cannot establish its conclusion.

Sufficient Assumptions

A sufficient condition is something that, by itself, guarantees the truth of a statement or conclusion.

If the sufficient condition is true, the conclusion must follow.

Example: Studying for the LSAT

Imagine we have the argument: "If you study for the LSAT, you will do well."

Let's think about this: Is studying for the LSAT enough to do well? What if you get poor sleep the night before, there is a band playing in the room next to you, or you get sick on test day?

Despite studying, you still might not do well due to other factors.

Studying is generally important for doing well on the exam. However, studying alone is not sufficient to guarantee a good result.

Words That Indicate Necessary Assumptions

Necessary Assumption questions often contain wording that emphasizes something the argument must rely on.

  • "Requires" or "Required"
    • "Which one of the following is required for the argument to be valid?"
    • "Which assumption is necessary for the conclusion to follow?"
  • "Relies On"
    • "Which of the following is an assumption that the argument relies on?"
  • "Depends On"
    • "The conclusion depends on which of the following?"
  • "Essential"
    • "Which assumption is essential to the argument?"
  • "Necessary"
    • "Which of the following assumptions is necessary for the argument?"

Words That Indicate Sufficient Assumptions

Sufficient Assumption questions typically ask which statement would make the conclusion follow logically.

  • "Guarantees" or "Guarantee"
    • "Which of the following assumptions, if true, would guarantee the conclusion?"
  • "Sufficient" or "Sufficient To"
    • "Which assumption is sufficient to justify the conclusion?"
  • "If True"
    • "Which of the following, if assumed, would make the conclusion follow?"
  • "Ensures"
    • "Which assumption ensures that the conclusion is valid?"
Remember:

Necessary Assumption questions ask what must be true for the reasoning to work. Sufficient Assumption questions ask what, if assumed, would guarantee that the conclusion follows.

The phrase "if true" alone does not identify a Sufficient Assumption question. Pay attention to whether the question asks for a guarantee.

What Is a Necessary Assumption Question?

Necessary Assumption questions ask you to determine what has to be true—but was never explicitly stated—in order for an argument to work. Stated differently, if a necessary assumption were discovered to be false, the argument would fall apart: the conclusion would no longer follow logically from its premises.

Necessary Assumption questions usually involve arguments that have something—or several things—missing. There's at least one significant gap.

When there's a gap in an argument (in other words, a missing link between support and conclusion), that argument is assuming something is true without stating it. In other words, it's an assumption.

How Do We Know It Is a Necessary Assumption Question?

Necessary Assumption questions ask you to identify a choice that has to be true in order for the reasoning of the argument to follow logically.

Common Question Stems:
  • "The argument relies on assuming which one of the following?"
  • "The argument depends on the assumption that..."
  • "Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?"

What Are Common Trap Answers?

  • Too Strong: When a choice is too strong, you'll want to ask yourself, "Does this statement really have to be true, to the degree that's expressed here, in order for the argument to hold? Or would a lesser version of this statement still work?"
  • Irrelevant: When a choice is irrelevant to the argument, you'll want to ask yourself, "Does this even matter to the argument, or is it just something that's 'nice to know' or confusing because it's irrelevant?"
  • Detrimental: Ask yourself, "Does the argument actually depend on this statement, or is it actually worse off in light of this statement?"

Necessary Assumption Strategy

TIPS & TRICKS

✓ Step 1: Use the Negation Test

The Negation Test helps you determine whether an assumption is necessary by testing what happens if that assumption is false. Specifically, you negate the assumption and check whether the argument still holds up.

  • If the argument collapses or becomes invalid when the assumption is negated, then the assumption is necessary.
  • If the argument still holds up when the assumption is negated, then it is not necessary.
Steps for the Negation Test:
  1. Identify the Assumption: First, look at the answer choices to identify a potential assumption that the argument relies on. The assumption is typically an unstated premise that bridges the gap between the evidence (premises) and the conclusion.
  2. Negate the Assumption: Take the selected assumption and imagine what would happen if it were false. The negation is the logical denial of the assumption, not necessarily its extreme opposite.
  3. Evaluate the Argument: See if the argument still makes sense or holds up logically when the assumption is negated.
    • If negating the assumption makes the conclusion fail to follow from the premises, then the assumption is necessary.
    • If negating the assumption does not undermine the argument's reasoning, then it is not necessary.

✓ Step 2: Be Aware of Traps

The LSAT loves to test tricky, subtle nuances. Be cautious of:

  • Extreme Language: Words like "always," "never," or "only" can indicate an overstatement, which may be irrelevant to the necessary assumption.
  • Irrelevant Information: Information that doesn't actually connect the premises to the conclusion.
  • Sufficient Assumptions: Answer choices that guarantee the conclusion may be stronger than what the argument actually requires.
Final Tip: The Negation Test Is Your Best Friend!

When you're stuck between two answer choices, negate each one and ask whether the argument can still support its conclusion. The correct necessary assumption is the statement the argument cannot do without.

Recent Posts

Leave a Reply