LSAT Identify the Principle / Propositions / Generalizations Questions
Learn how to identify principles in LSAT Logical Reasoning questions, recognize common question stems, understand different types of principles, and apply strategies to match general rules with specific situations.
What Is a Principle?
You can think of a principle as a general rule, definition, or value that can apply to many different specific scenarios. For example, "Sometimes, unforeseen challenges can make you stronger" is a principle that could govern an infinite number of specific situations, including these examples:
- Eobard lost his job at the same time that his partner broke off their relationship, leaving him feeling sad. Looking to distract himself, he signed up for a photography class and discovered a real passion for nature photography. This led to a lucrative and fulfilling career for Eobard.
- When Soon-Ling broke her hand, she was determined to learn how to use her non-dominant (right) hand. Now that her dominant hand is fully healed, Soon-Ling is ambidextrous in most activities.
3 Examples of Principles
1. Logical Principles
- "If one thing is true, then another thing must follow" (a principle of deductive reasoning).
- "A cause can only be established by clear and consistent evidence" (a principle of causal inference).
2. Ethical Principles
- "People should be held responsible for the harm their actions cause" (a moral principle).
- "Actions that violate individual freedoms are unjust" (a libertarian ethical principle).
3. Legal or Policy Principles
- "A law must treat all individuals equally" (a legal principle based on equality).
- "Policies should be designed to benefit the majority, unless doing so harms the rights of the minority" (a policy principle).
What Is an Identify the Principle Question?
In this question, you're asked to identify the principle that underlies the stimulus. Often, these passages contain a situation rather than a conclusion/support-based argument.
Usually, you won't want to make a prediction for argument-based passages, but you may be able to make one for situation-based passages. A principle for a situation-based passage would resemble principles that we use in everyday life, such as "It's better to be safe than sorry" or "Sometimes the solution to one problem creates a new problem."
Principles occasionally show up in several other question types, including Strengthen and Implications. For instance, the choices for a Strengthen question might take the form of principles that could support a claim.
How Do We Know It Is an Identify the Principle Question?
LSAT questions about principles (also called "propositions" or "generalizations") can take several forms:
Identify the Principle
The passage is an argument or a situation, and the principle is in the choices.
- Which one of the following generalizations is most clearly illustrated by the passage?
- Which one of the following principles, if valid, most helps to justify the reasoning in the editorial?
- The situation as Madden describes it best illustrates which one of the following propositions?
Find a Situation That Conforms to a Principle
The choices are all arguments or situations, and the principle is in the passage.
- Which one of the following judgments conforms most closely to the principle cited by the columnist?
- Which one of the following provides the best illustration of the principle above?
What Are Common Trap Answer Choices?
Wrong choices will often contain pieces that aren't relevant to the scope of the argument. In principles that justify questions, wrong choices will be very similar to wrong choices in Strengthen questions—they'll either weaken the argument or have no impact.
Identify Principle Strategy
TIPS & TRICKS✓ Step 1: Understand What a Principle Is
- On the LSAT, a principle refers to a general rule, guideline, or reasoning pattern that underlies an argument or situation presented in the test. Principles are often abstract, broad, and reflect a generalized approach to how things should work, be evaluated, or be applied in a given context.
✓ Step 2: Understand and Identify the Principle
- Understand the three key types of principles on the previous pages so you know what to look out for when reading the stimulus.
- Keep that principle simple but accurate. If you're having trouble identifying the principle, ask yourself what the arguer seems to value. Why do they recommend, predict, or compare what they do?
✓ Step 3: Restate the Argument/Situation
- If the passage is an argument, it's good to identify the conclusion and support. If the passage is situational instead of argumentative, restate the situation in your own words. What's happening, and how do the pieces of action affect each other?
✓ Step 4: Diagram if Necessary
- This will be most often helpful in questions that give you the principle in the passage, then ask you to find the situation that illustrates or conforms to that principle. The principle is often presented in the form of conditional logic, which many students find helpful to map out with their pencil.
✓ Step 5: Compare Each Choice Against the Stimulus
- Which one accomplishes the task?