Reach out to ask any questions about our services! Call or Text (973) 566-5236 or Email Team@PrepForSuccessTutors.com

LSAT Must Be True Tips

LSAT Identify the Entailment / Must Be True Questions

General Information

Learn how to approach LSAT Must Be True questions, recognize common trap answers, apply formal logic, and identify conclusions that are guaranteed by the information provided.

What Is an Identify the Entailment Question?

Identify the Entailment questions / Must Be True questions often test your ability to read and understand the stimulus and then find an answer choice that 100% HAS to be true based on the information that you read. It can't maybe be true. It HAS to be true. So you don't want to make any assumptions here. You're pulling information directly from the stimulus and finding the answer that is undoubtedly supported!

How Do We Know It Is an Identify the Entailment Question?

Look for questions that ask you what must be true, or for what logically follows; sometimes the question asks you instead for what the conclusion would have to be if the statements in the stimulus are true.

Examples:
  • If the statements above are true, which one of the following must also be true?
  • Which one of the following logically follows from the statements above?
  • Which one of the following can be properly inferred from the statements above?

What Are Common Trap Answer Choices?

  • Too Strong/Extreme: Some wrong choices are statements that go beyond the truth of the passage by being too extreme.
  • Probably/Might Be True: Some wrong choices are statements that could very well be true but that we can't be 100% certain about.

Must Be True Formal Logic

Simple Example

Example of Must Be True Formal Logic:

Which one of these must be true based on the information given below?

All dogs are mammals.
Spot is a dog.

A) Spot is a mammal
B) Spot is not a mammal
C) Spot is like all dogs

Correct Answer: A

Which one of these must be true based on the information given below?

K or L --> M
P --> not M
not K --> L

A) K --> P
B) P --> not L
C) M --> L

Correct Answer: B

Must Be True Formal Logic

Example 1: Conditional Logic (If...Then)

Argument:

If it rains, the ground will be wet. It is raining. Therefore, the ground is wet.

  1. Premise 1: If it rains → the ground is wet. (This is a conditional statement: If P, then Q.)
  2. Premise 2: It is raining. This confirms P (it rains).
  3. Conclusion: The ground is wet. Based on If P, then Q, and P is true (it is raining), we can infer that Q (the ground is wet) must be true.

Formal Logic Representation:

  • If P → Q (If it rains, the ground is wet).
  • P (It is raining).
  • Therefore, Q (The ground is wet).

Must Be True Question:

Which of the following must be true?

Answer Choices:

  • A) The ground is wet.
  • B) It is raining.
  • C) The ground might be wet.
  • D) If the ground is wet, it must have rained.
  • E) The ground will be wet every time it rains.
Correct Answer:

A) The ground is wet.

  • Explanation: The argument follows the structure of If P, then Q, and since P (it is raining) is true, we must conclude that Q (the ground is wet) is true.

Must Be True Formal Logic

Example 2: Negation & Elimination

Argument:

If it is a dog, then it has four legs. It is not a dog. Therefore, it does not have four legs.

  1. Premise 1: If it is a dog → it has four legs.
  2. Premise 2: It is not a dog. This is the negation of the first part of the conditional statement.
  3. Conclusion: It does not have four legs. This is the critical point: negating the "dog" part does not necessarily mean the animal doesn't have four legs. There could be other animals with four legs.

Formal Logic Representation:

  • If P → Q (If it is a dog, it has four legs).
  • ¬P (It is not a dog).
  • Therefore, ¬Q (It does not have four legs).

This is invalid logic. You cannot conclude that it doesn't have four legs just because it's not a dog.

Must Be True Question:

Which of the following must be true?

Answer Choices:

  • A) The animal is not a dog.
  • B) The animal might not have four legs.
  • C) The animal has four legs.
  • D) If the animal is not a dog, it does not have four legs.
  • E) The animal could have four legs.
Correct Answer:

E) The animal could have four legs.

  • Explanation: The argument does not provide any information about whether animals that aren't dogs can have four legs. Therefore, the answer "the animal could have four legs" must be true, since there's no prohibition against it.

Must Be True Strategy

TIPS & TRICKS

✓ Step 1: Ask What Is Guaranteed?

  • Understand the argument: First, carefully read the argument and identify the premises (the supporting statements or facts) and the conclusion (the claim the argument is trying to prove).
  • What's guaranteed? A Must Be True question asks you to find something that is absolutely true given the information. You should focus on the facts in the argument that must logically follow from the premises.

✓ Step 2: Eliminate Extreme Qualifiers Answer

  • Extreme language (like "always," "never," or "all") can be a red flag. Be cautious of answers that make sweeping claims unless the argument explicitly supports them.
  • Similarly, answers that are too specific (e.g., referring to a very particular detail that wasn't covered in the argument) should be eliminated.
  • For Must Be True questions, you want Weak Language.

✓ Step 3: Verify "Could"/"Might" vs. "Must" Be True

  • The answer that seems "likely" but isn't necessarily true: It may be tempting to pick an answer that feels plausible, but make sure it's directly supported by the information in the argument. Keep in mind, this question type is MUST be true, not COULD be true.

✓ Step 4: Look for Conditionals

  • Conditionals (if-then statements) play an important role because they help you understand logical relationships between different propositions or facts presented in the argument. These conditional statements can clarify what must follow from the premises.

✓ Step 5: Use the "Proof" Method

  • Test each answer choice: For each option, ask yourself: "Does this logically follow from the premises?" If the answer is yes for a particular choice, that is likely the correct answer.
  • Look for the most certain answer: If you're stuck between two options, choose the one that is most directly supported by the premises.
Recent Posts

Leave a Reply